Skip to content

Monthly Archives: May 2010

Noted elsewhere: Tocqueville in America.

A European observer would probably be struck by the unpeopled landscape and the alligators, the intense local and voluntary involvement (a congregation, a united small community), but also by the defiant individualism—the solitary seeker rigged up as if for nineteenth-century missionary work—and, of course, the slightly insane theological certainties.

Far from the clockwork universe.

Anthony O’Hear: Perhaps our days are not quite so tolerant, after all. The two figures who loom over the book as a whole and over many of the individual chapters are the now largely forgotten nineteenth century writers, Andrew Dickson White and John William Draper. Both argued noisily and vociferously that religion in general and Christianity, especially Catholic Christianity, in particular had been major obstacles to scientific progress and discovery, and it is against this view that most of the articles are directed.

Noted Elsewhere: The Ramadan complex.

The book may only recapitulate much of what’s been said and screamed over the Western intelligentsia’s embrace of the charismatic Islamist Tariq Ramadan and and its wincing alienation of the atheist feminist Ayaan Hirsi Ali, but if that’s all it does, it’ll be enough.

Noted elsewhere: The new war between science and religion.

Unlike the old science-religion war, this battle is going to be fought not in the courts but in the arena of public opinion. The new war pits those who argue that science and “moderate” forms of religion are compatible worldviews against those who think they are not.

Invented urination in Paris.

 Harry Stein: Who knew, for example, that the Breton bonnet Charlotte Corday wore in the tumbrel en route to the guillotine would give rise to a fashion craze? (And, yet, knowing, who can truly be surprised?) But after a while, even such details become suspect.

Noted elsewhere: Europe is unprepared for austerity.

By GIDEON RACHMAN [Financial Times] – Most of the European Union is living beyond its means. Government deficits are out of control and public-sector debt is rising. If European governments do not use their new breathing space to control spending, financial markets will get dangerously restless again. Unfortunately, European voters and politicians are simply unprepared […]

Noted elsewhere: Little modern magazines.

…in the last years of the nineteenth century, a number of dissident priests and some misled laity, calling themselves modernists, tried to force the Church to abandon some of its principles: to concede the primacy of science over faith…

Noted elsewhere: Contemporary Orthodox Turks.

The Orthodox community has been supplemented to some degree by Russians who have taken up permanent residence there. However, there are also some Turks who have become Orthodox in the Patriarchate.

Occ. Notes: 'What's in a name?'

In an attempt to cleanse its book reviews of commercial and political overtones, The Fortnightly Review transformed critical writing by implementing an editorial policy of signature.

Noted elsewhere: André Derain: The Pool of London.

TATE MODERN – In 1905 Derain had travelled with Matisse to Collioure in southern France where they had experimented with this brilliantly-coloured style – Matisse painted a portrait of Derain, and Derain one of Matisse. They tried to create dynamic compositions using  complementary colours, such as red and green, which appear most intense when placed […]

Noted elsewhere: A great fiery explosion called Delacroix.

By JULIAN BARNES [The Times Literary Supplement] – In 1937, the American art critic Walter Pach edited and translated the first English-language version of Eugène Delacroix’s Journal. In his introduction he recorded a story told him decades previously by Odilon Redon. In 1861, the young Redon, yet to make his name, had gone to a […]

Dostoyevski and the religion of suffering 1.

Eugène-Melchior de Vogüé: In commenting on the labours and life of this man I invite the reader to accompany me on a journey, always sad, often frightful, at times ominous. Those who feel a repugnance on entering hospitals, courts of justice, prisons, and who are afraid to pass through a cemetery at night, had best keep away. Part one of a five-part series.

Noted elsewhere: Over to Dave.

By PAUL LINFORD – ‘Messrs Harman, Mandelson, Johnson and Co have talked all night in language that suggested an attempt would be made to form some sort of Lib-Lab pact, but given how the two parties have performed I think it would be pretty politically unsustainable. ‘Although it is still possible the Tories may win […]

Noted elsewhere: Fate of the nation.

Britain is in trouble. This election comes at a time when the quiet assumptions of our nation and its politics are in question. It is no longer clear that Britain will be able to remain a great power, or a harmonious society, or one prosperous enough to be able to guarantee its citizens liberty and justice.

Noted elsewhere: Parties and People: England (1914-51).

By VERNON BOGDANOR [New Statesman] – A hundred years ago, we seemed about to witness the strange death, not of Liberal England, as George Dangerfield suggested in his book, but of Conservative England. The hold of the Liberals on government, buttressed as it was by the Irish nationalists and the infant Labour Party, seemed unshakeable. […]